The Jim Edmonds Experiment
Sunday, May 25th, 2008Edmonds has gone 2-16 with 1 BB and nothing else in four starts and one pinch-hitting appearance over nine games. Over the same span, remarkably also four starts and one pinch-hitting appearance, Reed Johnson is 5-18 with 2 BB, 5 R, 6 RBI, 2 2B, 1 HR. Is this enough sample size to make a determination on whether to keep him? Probably not. But the first two weeks of the Jim Edmonds Experiment have certainly shown the combination of Edmonds’ age and injuries make him look over-matched in the batter’s box, even falling down on one occasion.
It was a no risk signing, as long as you know when to pull the plug. Bottom line is unless he has a nice hot streak at the dish over the next two weeks, I think you’ll see him released/designated for assignment. The question will be will the Cubs let Johnson start everyday until the All-Star break and allow Micah Hoffpauir be the fourth outfielder, and then evaluate both Johnson and Hoffpauir’s offensive performance against the trade market as teams start dumping players. I think that’s the best choice the Cubs have right now.



